COMMISSION EVALUATION / 7 MIN READ

Comparing forex IB programmes: look beyond the advertised rate

Compare FX introducing broker programmes using eligible activity, account types, attribution, payment terms and reporting evidence, with a fictional worked example.

A headline rate is only useful once its calculation basis, eligibility and payment conditions are known. Compare documented terms against the same activity assumptions and keep unresolved conditions visible.

Start with the sentence after “up to”

A forex IB offer can look easy to compare: a percentage on one page, a dollar amount per lot on another. The difficulty starts when you ask what those figures apply to. Which accounts count? Which instruments? Is the percentage taken from the spread, a defined revenue amount or something else?

Write down the offer exactly, then ask for the applicable programme terms and dated commission schedule. Keep the broker entity and the intended partner and client locations with the evidence. A public page can explain a programme without proving that its maximum rate is available to a particular applicant.

Pepperstone's global IB page, for example, expressly warns that programme terms and rewards vary by jurisdiction and some are unavailable in certain regions. That qualification belongs in a comparison, alongside the offer. The named providers in this article illustrate reporting and commercial distinctions; they are not a ranking or recommendation.

Use the same activity assumptions on both sides

Build a small activity mix rather than multiplying every lot by the largest advertised number. Include the account types and instruments relevant to the proposed relationship. State the measurement unit precisely: lots and traded notional are different quantities, and the meaning of a lot depends on the instrument's contract specification.

Exness's published reward structure distinguishes spread-based rewards from fixed per-lot rewards according to account type and instrument, and also describes tier requirements. This is one provider's structure, not a formula to apply to the rest of the market.

In the fictional comparison below, both plans are evaluated against 200 closed standard FX lots, with commission denominated in USD. Both fictional rates apply to completed round-turn volume. Plan A's assumed terms cover all 200 lots at USD 6 per eligible lot. Plan B advertises USD 8, but its assumed account-type restriction leaves only 140 lots eligible. The remaining 60 are excluded under that fictional plan. No other fees, onward shares or adjustments are included.

Fictional arithmetic illustration, not broker offers or an earnings forecast
Assumption or resultPlan APlan B
Activity under review200 closed standard FX lots200 closed standard FX lots
Assumed eligible activity200 lots140 lots; 60 excluded
Assumed rateUSD 6 per eligible lotUSD 8 per eligible lot
Calculated gross commissionUSD 1,200USD 1,120
If eligibility is unconfirmedCalculation remains provisionalCalculation remains provisional

Keep a terms-and-evidence worksheet

The higher nominal rate in that example produces the lower calculated amount under the stated assumptions. Change the activity mix or eligibility and the result can change again. Neither calculation shows the amount ultimately received, the cost of serving clients or whether the programme is appropriate for the business.

Use the following worksheet in a spreadsheet or your own document. Add one column per offer and enter the evidence reference beside each answer. An empty field is a question for the provider, not permission to assume the most favourable interpretation.

Commercial comparison worksheet for each proposed forex IB relationship
QuestionRecordEvidence to request
Who is offering the arrangement?Entity, programme, territory and applicant scopeApplicable terms and approval
What creates an eligible earning?Attribution, account type, instrument, qualifying event and exclusionsCommission schedule and qualification definition
What is the calculation base?Per lot, notional, defined spread/revenue or qualified acquisitionFormula and worked provider example
What changes the rate?Tier test, measurement window and effective dateDated tier schedule and change notices
When does money become available?Calculation, credit, withdrawal and settlement stagesPayment terms, thresholds and charges
What can revise an amount?Adjustments, reversals, corrections and dispute processRelevant terms and supporting report
Can the amount be checked?Report fields, stable references and export availabilityAn authorized sample with sensitive data removed

Check the event that earns the commission

Keep an IB activity-based arrangement separate from an affiliate acquisition payment. A CPA qualification can depend on events that a recurring trading reward does not use in the same way. Do not put the two rates in adjacent cells and treat the units as equal.

Ask how the provider confirms the referral, whether additional trading accounts follow the same attribution and which activity is excluded. If a programme requires approval of the traffic source or client region, retain that approval for the relationship under review. The fact that a portal accepts a registration does not answer every commercial question.

Keep any uncertain eligibility separate from confirmed eligible activity in your comparison. If the necessary detail is unavailable, show the amount as unknown or provide clearly labelled conditional scenarios. A precise-looking total built on an unanswered eligibility question is still an unanswered question.

Read “paid daily” as a question about stages

A reward appearing in a portal, becoming withdrawable and reaching a bank account are different events. Ask which event a payment-frequency claim describes, whether a withdrawal threshold applies, who bears transfer charges and how a failed or delayed payment is reported.

OANDA Global Markets' BVI introducing-broker page illustrates this distinction: it describes daily updates in the IB portal and end-of-month bank payouts. Those are the stated details of that entity's page, not a universal OANDA schedule or a promise about an individual arrangement.

Request an authorized sample report before relying on a dashboard screenshot. Check whether it carries the programme reference, currency, relevant dates, source IDs and any adjustments. A reviewer should be able to explain a changed amount without guessing which previous row it replaced.

End with a decision that shows its conditions

A useful comparison ends with a short record: the entity and programme assessed, terms version, activity assumptions, unresolved questions and the evidence still needed. If the commercial decision depends on a rate or territory approval that has not been confirmed, say so.

Keep the client's trading costs and the services you are permitted to provide in that decision. A larger partner payment alone does not establish better client outcomes. This worksheet is for operating and reporting comparisons; it does not establish regulatory permission or replace advice on an applicable agreement.

After a relationship is approved, retain its dated terms alongside the subsequent statement reviews. IBDock can support review of imported statement data, but an import does not negotiate the programme, verify every eligibility condition or execute commission payments.

Put the method to work.

Try the sample workspace. No broker password required.

Review a fictional USD statement

Sources and scope

Editorial scope: product reporting guidance with fictional examples. No paid broker placement, investment recommendation or independent audit claim. Product capabilities are described as of the update date shown above.

Report a guide issue or suggest a correction →

Continue reading

Multi-broker IB operations: adding a second FX broker ↗

IB commission structure: per lot, CPA, revenue share and tiers ↗

IB commission payment differences: partial payments, fees and carry-forward ↗